This past weekend, I was on the way to coach a basketball game. For those that don’t know, when I’m not here writing and making videos about video games, classic movies, and LeBron James, I‘m an assistant coach for a little league basketball team. My head coach was kind enough to give me a ride to the game. I wasn’t sure what our conversations would be during the hour-long drive (there’s only so much you can game-plan when it comes to 11-year old boys). Thankfully, I’d learnt that he was just as much of a nerd as me. So, we went through the usual rigmarole of asking what each other’s favourite games and anime were. Eventually, we landed on the topic of GTA VI. He‘s quite excited for Rockstar’s much-anticipated title, and believes, like many do, that this game is going to be revolutionary. I, however, don’t (or, at least, didn’t at the time) share such a sentiment.
Don’t get me wrong, I understand the significance of Grand Theft Auto when it comes to the gaming zeitgeist. I understand the hype for GTA VI. I was just never a GTA guy. I’d played them growing up, sure, but the only ones I’d ever finished were GTA IV & V, and I only truly loved the former. Red Dead Redemption was much more my speed when it came to Rockstar’s IPs. Nevertheless, I know what Rockstar and their games mean for the gaming industry. I know that when they release a game, we expect the bar to be raised. They raised it with GTA III, then again with Vice City and San Andreas, then again with the remarkable physics and storytelling of IV, and again with V. They did the same with both Red Dead Redemption titles, too.

Still, even though their track record has been pretty perfect over the past two and a half decades, I still wasn’t sure if GTA VI would be able to meet those incredibly lofty expectations. I wasn’t sure if this game would even crack the “90s” on aggregate sites like Opencritic. My saying so had my head coach aghast. “Of course it will! There’s no shot it doesn’t,” he exclaimed. And, like a good contrarian, I shrugged and simply said, “I don’t know, coach, it might not. Not in 2026.”
Now, why would I say such a blasphemous thing? Well, mostly because Rockstar have been out of the game for nearly a decade, and some of their game design sensibilities also haven’t aged as gracefully. For as amazing as RDR2 was and is, we’ve had other games push boundaries and raise the bar, visually and mechanically, since 2018. Games like Baldur‘s Gate 3, Tears of the Kingdom, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, Kingdom Come: Deliverance II, and Alan Wake 2, to name a few, all blew us away with either their cinematic storytelling, audiovisuals, open-world gameplay, and/or immersive RPG mechanics. I’d argue that they all, in one way or another, surpass RDR2 in certain aspects.
We’ve had some incredibly high highs and some tremendously low lows since Rockstar’s last outing, both within gaming and outside of it. From COVID to politicians toying with global calamity to the rise of AI existentialism to gaming companies f*cking us over every chance they get, it’s been…rough. Between those moments of dread, however, we did get some incredible games, especially within the indie space. Too many games, in fact. So, as we grow up in these uncertain times, while also being inundated with both remarkable and remarkably bad video games frying our dopamine receptors, it makes for a combination that leads us (me) to be less enthused by modern gaming.

It reminds me of a comment I’d read on Reddit by user SonderSoft, who responded to a post made by someone asking why they felt gaming wasn’t exciting anymore. Their respond reads as follows: “Pinch of depression, a dash of too much insight into game design to make things predictable, and a large dollop of infinite content vying for your attention. Bake for 30-40 years and voila!”
That comment sums up everything I’m trying to convey here, and is much of the reason why I thought that GTA VI, for the type of game it is (or, at least, I thought it was) wouldn’t resonate with critics the same way it may have a few years ago. Couple that with the fact that we’re seeing more and more global outlets be a part of these aggregate sites, making room for more outlier scores and potentially bringing down the overall number, and I was genuinely certain this game wouldn’t get more than a 92.
Clearly, I don’t know what the f*ck I’m talking about because, as of writing, Grand Theft Auto VI is sitting at a 99 on both Opencritic and Metacritic. A score that matches the original Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time on the N64 as the highest rated game of all time. Doing so with over a hundred critical reviews, no less.
Damn, Rockstar. I could not be happier that my negative Nancy butt was wrong. I still don’t know if I’ll love the game as much as everyone else, but, hey, we’ll find out in t-minus 10 minutes, as of writing. I also guess I owe my head coach a pizza or something.


Leave a Reply